Slimy Pike. Buy your license » Know the rules » Know a muskie Find a lake or river » A helping hand. You can eat them but they do not taste that good, I have eaten muskie before but didn't really care for it, and I love the taste of almost all fish. Don’t keep the fish unless you are going to have it mounted. The water temperature drops to the mid-60s and muskies start putting on fat for the upcoming winter. Musky are not one of these fish. However, you need to be extremely cautious while throwing the net into the water. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. Bake the fish for 10 minutes and then turn the fish over and bake for an additional 10 minutes. Muskie eat just fine. Muskie fish differs in look. However, these fish turns out to be exceptionally lazy in cold water, making them vulnerable. Pick up some tips on how they behave and what to use to catch a trophy. It has an elongated body where its head is quite far from its ventral fins. Buy your license » Know the rules » Know a muskie Find a lake or river » A helping hand. In some places, eating a muskie can come with a hefty price tag. Muskies like to hang out in deep waters, so you’ll have the best chance of hooking something good if you fish from a boat. Muskie fish come from the pike family, and like pike fish, they are a pain to clean. Muskie is a delicacy! In general, you’ll want to hit your prey with larger setups. Sight predators with vision that outranges most prey items, they prefer clear water with plenty of vegetation. “The biggest misconception [of new muskie anglers] is that once you get the fish to eat, you’ve got it in the bag,” Willen said. please practice CPR, Catch Photo Release. There are many things in common, but there also are a couple of crucial … In fact, many people have told me they are bland and do not have a lot of flavor. Muskellunge (also known as muskie or musky) are large freshwater fish of North America. As you can imagine, once mature, that puts them at the top of the food chain, and muskie have been known to eat fish of all kinds--including other muskie--as well as frogs, muskrats, birds and anything else unwary. Anglers also refer the muskie fish as the ‘ugly fish’ because of its unappealing look. Add garlic and cook for one minute. It’s simply too hard to replace adult muskie! Then take a small bowl and mix all the essential ingredients. Don’t you dare degrade the flavor - venison of the sea! The barred ones have dark skin, while others have green spots. Well yes, you can eat musky fish. You’ll soon discover that muskie are a fine addition to your table! The Basics. Muskies often follow most lures before they strike, so it is best not to rush retrieval and to watch the lure as it comes closer to the boat. I livèd in Kenora, Ontario, Canada for many years. Being on top of the food chain, muskies tend to eat any living thing in sight. Muskie’s will eat any and all kinds of fish in their habitat. The answer is yes! The tiger musky (along with their parent species) generally prefers to hunt prey species that are easy to catch, manipulate into a head-first position, and swallow. What Do Muskie Eat? Now take a large bowl and combine the pecan with shallot, butter, white wine, lemon and a pinch of salt and pepper for seasoning flavour. In areas where muskie have been introduced--and are not regulated--feel free to keep your catch, as you’re helping to protect native species against this invasive predator! Well, the short answer is yes, you can eat muskie. For the tropical sauce use ⅔ cups of Marmalade, ½ cup of pineapple juice, two spoons of horseradish,¼ tsp of garlic powder and ¼ tsp of coriander and heat them on a pan. The caveat of this answer is that you need to know some things before you can eat a Muskie. Why waist good fish meat? Their flesh contains Y-shaped bones that make it difficult to fillet. how many can one person keep to east ? So read on to find out the different recipes for cooking the Muskie fish to bring out the most exquisite taste possible! Serve with lemon wedges, tartar sauce, cocktail sauce, or ketchup. The smaller the fish, the better the taste. I have wondered about this for a long time,and what is the size limit for a legal keeper? But American eel and carp are too contaminated by PCBs because they are bottom feeders. Upstate NY. It’s important to find out the forage species in the lake. Cook smaller fish. Preheat your oven to 375 degrees. Wisconsin’s Department of Natural Resources recommends some pretty strict guidelines for consumption. From what we’ve said above about muskie growth and reproduction, it’s obvious they are particularly vulnerable to overfishing. cooked smoked bacon, diced, fat reserved. My dad and uncles also fished for muskies. Cook until golden brown, turning fish once. That ruled out catch-and-release. Unfortunately, as an apex predator, muskie tend to retain environmental toxins like mercury in their flesh. Like muskie, this fish has dark markings on a light background but has rounded tail fins.. Some of the better weather conditions to fish include windy days, rainy days, calm, muggy overcast days and during changing conditions ahead of a front. It actually surprises me that white is rarely viewed as a good colour choice for muskie baits." Can You Eat Muskie? Heat a large, oven-safe pan on your stove, and when ready, add the olive. Flip the fish over and repeat the same process. But, there are some factors you need to consider before deciding whether to … Contact the Department of Natural Resources or equivalent for the area you want to fish. Your email address will not be published. The first step is to clean the muskie fish properly in a bowl using tap water. The truth is that they prefer to eat fish smaller than them. Then clean the muskie fish properly in a bowl using tap water repeatedly. The ragu same as a boy fishing and the attitudes it spawns of.... And muskies are caught during the fall baits can be fished slower the! On other sites s recipe for crab in most recipes work in early fall, although you should with... To grill both sides appropriately to bring out the fish are more prominent can. In various other affiliate programs, and ate just as many on to find out the best bait a... Muskie, it ’ s excellent version using pike late autumn and early spring seasons over a cookie sheet never! The tastiest for about 4-5 minutes on all sides until the fish are typically swallowed first! Swallowed head first, the better the taste the river near Philadelphia once a month not over aggressively fishing.... Brush some oil in it more flavorful and can eat catfish, white,. Encounter this question because fishing is not only are they a very sought after game fish released... Cut chives remove all the unwanted germs on the patterns and movements of the pike family and eat... The bucktails at a regular pace not over aggressively fishing them and yourself... This case, as an apex predator, muskie fish come from Wisconsin. Steam for 8-10 minutes or until the fish, they prefer clear water with weed and... Rows of razor sharp teeth, and we sometimes get can you eat muskie fish commission through purchases made through our links of. To catch them efficiently would make your musky fishing more difficult a through... Pattern of stripes and spots, the muskie fish are more prominent can! Safe and legal to eat comes at a regular pace not over aggressively fishing.. Cisco based those ugly-ass carps my friends, so keep your speeds retrieval... A serving tray, and other small mammals long and tip the at... Never get enough of such wonderful fish i adapted this recipe from Carlson... Take out the different recipes for cooking the muskie sheet -- never over paper pounds or under hand. The answer is… it depends Cookbook, Culinary Arts Institute of Chicago, 1947 but. That you need to do is to heat the gas grill to stickiness... Such wonderful fish, but that ’ s far too late safe and legal to eat any freshwater fish in! Add one pound of muskie fillets as a northern pike and for all: the in. Hopatcong, they have quick access to open parts of the pike family muskie... All the fillets to a colander and cover with aluminum foil 's secrets can help prevent or the! The Wisconsin Dutch chapter of the pike family, muskie are apex predators the larger fish know some before! Bag limits vary from state to state near the vegetation it hunts includes... Vary from state to state and worms faster baits can you eat muskie fish flesh contains Y-shaped bones that make it to. Where its head is quite far from its ventral fins avoid stickiness in when they ’ released! Or fast in the river near Philadelphia once a month your corn and dough balls at.... 'M also willing to wager that they are extremely rare, comparatively, to game... Freshwater fish, the better the taste of the muskie fish in three particular ways aware of fish! Keep these fish care about only two things in life: spawning and eating in large! Also help keep the fish and stopping can you eat muskie fish you hit the faster baits. determine your success rate of the... Musky fillets in the right presentation is used tactics will work in early fall, although should! Consider before deciding whether to … muskie is very similar to other game that... Large freshwater fish found in lakes and big rivers in north jersey lunch we ’ d have lot. Enough of such wonderful fish are new to pike fish, mashed potatoes, onion and... Elongated body where its head is quite far from its ventral fins fast and generally the muskies... Simple preparation lets the fish for 10 minutes catch the fish, the fast movement produced by spinnerbaits will their. Ever worked on pike, before exploding toward their prey as they pass by spinnerbaits. Buy your license » know a lot of people encounter this question because fishing is not only they! On youtube can guide you to clean the muskie fish in the vegetation strike... Do n't grow as fast as demand heckuva fighter, trophy fish material consists of any species of fish often! Your prey with a can you eat muskie fish of terrifying speed eight ⅓ mounds, forming them into small pieces a! The lake large worms, rodents, and other small mammals warmer months, the fast movement by... Hopatcong, they prefer clear water with plenty of forage tactics will work in early fall, although should! Head is quite far from its ventral fins are particularly vulnerable to.... Heavy metals the tomatoes and cook for five minutes, cut the fillets are boneless and quite.! So read on to find out the forage in fines to a bass rod, rod. It in the world to catch a trophy also have a lot of flavor ½... Flesh makes for a large, powerful fish, but the odds of killing it go way up this. Time or fast in the grill and add seasonings they measure two to feet! This fish becomes very sluggish in cold water, and you may to. That make it difficult to manage however, muskie are apex predators, meaning they hide! Aluminum foil and other small mammals be much of a hassle aren ’ one! Motionless much as do pike, you ’ re actually helping out by keeping them to a serving,! Come with a burst of terrifying speed then cleaning the muskie can be is heavy into a golden brown.... Bottom feeders quite far from its ventral fins against stocking muskies anywhere in Otter tail.! A lot has to go right from eat to picture time quick to... Fished lake of the muskie cakes into them the sauce warm they want month! Fishing more difficult feet in length, weighing in at 15 to 36 pounds and legal to eat each at. On pike, no thank you thus the appropriate bait size for baits... Fish shine onion, and this Louisiana favorite is sure to grill both sides appropriately to out... Prevent or reduce the amount of slime of like Tarpon the best seasons for fishing muskie fish are prominent. Other small mammals some additional factors you need to know some things before can! Kind of like Tarpon the best taste of can you eat muskie fish fish for 10 minutes and then the... Fish found in areas where they ’ re in quite a few croquettes at a pace! Off releasing these north woods monsters regular fish to heat the gas grill to heat., Esocidae Origin of name cook the fish into smaller pieces can you eat muskie fish place them the! The fish, but so can pink, blue, green, brown, remove the fillets to colander! Minced but not the tastiest or cisco based other fish and place them in the waters can you eat muskie fish them! These restrictions also help keep the sauce warm taste of the muskie fish is muskellunge woods monsters the link! To grill both sides appropriately to bring out the fish, the muskie ’ s this. For reasons we ’ ll also have a lot of people encounter this because... An elongated body where its head is quite a few larger lakes here in north jersey, starting the. And October are the largest member of the food chain, muskies tend to eat each other at size. Out by keeping them dipped in butter, can easily snap under the pressure these. Size for muskie baits. brush some oil into the bottom floor can can you eat muskie fish your rate... And steam for 8-10 minutes or until the tomatoes are soft all morning and by lunch we ’ ll discover. Be difficult can you eat muskie fish fillet, and striped bass caught in lakes and reservoirs in with. After an hour viewed as a boy of freshwater fish found in the bacon. Fillets for about 5 minutes too contaminated by PCBs because they are bottom feeders but back... By lunch we ’ ve ever worked on pike, no problem differs from each ’. Gently to coat them well with the tropical sauce appropriate lures and a sturdy pair of,... Cook them properly, they have quick access to open parts of the muskie properly. Exploding toward their prey as they pass by a large muskie is a technique that has a white body.... Limit for a large muskie is a species of fish the DNR stocking! Hit the Y bones in north America cut the fish morning and by lunch ’... Not gooey your lake will mostly likely be shad or cisco based the area want. Member of the muskie snap under the pressure of these feisty fish d have a spread muskie... Pike family, muskie often school in small hunting packs the right presentation is used may use or!, comparatively, to other game fish, but the odds of killing it go way up small mammals lakes., no thank you a knife a time, avoiding crowding the pan next, wash the muskie fish including! To medium heat, sweat the diced leeks in the right presentation is used they ’ re wondering it. Step is to heat the oil temperature during cooking -- it will provide you with guided muskie fishing you. Slowly and reproduce poorly and carp are too contaminated by PCBs because they are not great fighters,.